An analysis of the views on cloning a controversial issue

No human being and no society can afford to be callous to the needs of suffering humanity, or cavalier about the treatment of nascent human life, or indifferent to the social effects of adopting one course of action rather than another.

And by enacting a four-year moratorium on the creation of cloned embryos, it establishes an additional safeguard not afforded by policies that would allow the production of cloned embryos to proceed without delay.

Controversies in Science: Cloning

Speaking only for ourselves, we acknowledge the following difficulties, but think that they can be addressed by setting proper boundaries. Speaking only for ourselves, those of us who support this recommendation do so for some or all of the following reasons: Thus, eight clones will be borne to different mothers.

Yamanaka, Induced pluripotent stem cells in medicine and biology. Islam[ edit ] The prominent Qatari scholar Yusuf Al Qaradawi believes that cloning specific parts of the human body for medical purposes is not prohibited in Islambut cloning the whole human body would not be permitted under any circumstances.

Since then, the fear-mongering has partly died down, but not before a great deal of draconian legislation was enacted across the world. This effectively took the place of SCNT as a reprogramming technology, as it was accepted as a less controversial form of deriving pluripotent stem cells.

To be effective as long-term treatments, cell transplantation therapies will have to overcome the immune rejection problem. It also indicated that it was possible for the DNA in differentiated somatic body cells to revert to an undifferentiated embryonic stage, thereby reestablishing pluripotency —the potential of an embryonic cell to grow into any one of the numerous different types of mature body cells that make up a complete organism.

Unlike natural reproduction, wherein the egg contains a combination of genetic material, this egg which grows into an embryo contains only the donor's gene.

Human Cloning: Unmasking the Controversy

Even when genetically identical twins are born, their embryo splits spontaneously or randomly to give a new unique genetic combination. The Ethics of Cloning-for-Biomedical-Research Ethical assessment of cloning-for-biomedical-research is far more vexing.

What do you believe? Looking back, in more than a half-century of research, reprogramming experiments have demonstrated the remarkable flexibility of our cells to be converted into different cell types that can serve as the basis for regenerative therapies.

Check new design of our homepage!

Controversial essay on Human Cloning - A dangerous invention

This egg then divides into an embryo. Over the years, cloning has come to mean an artificial and identical genetic copy of an existing life form. However, dissenters lost the political debate almost before it began. Rarely has such a seemingly small innovation raised such big questions.

The Legal and Ethical Issues of Cloning That Make it Controversial

In James Thompson derived the first human embryonic stem cells [3]. From pure scientific analysis, it was unprecedented milestone in the field of genetic engineering technologybut the news created a fetter among the moralists, government US president Mr.

The asexual production of a new human organism that is, at all stages of development, genetically virtually identical to a currently existing or previously existing human being.

This is the most important advantage of this proposal. In British developmental biologist Ian Wilmut generated a cloned sheep, named Dollyby means of nuclear transfer involving an enucleated embryo and a differentiated cell nucleus.

Moral status of the cloned embryo. Creating cloned embryos for any purpose requires crossing a major moral boundary, with grave risks and likely harms, and once we cross it there will be no turning back.

Even if we did conceive a human embryo through SCNT, and we then managed to bring it to term, the odds are very high that the result would be a seriously deformed child.

While we take seriously concerns about the treatment of nascent human life, we believe there are sound moral reasons for not regarding the embryo in its earliest stages as the moral equivalent of a human person.

The realization that the DNA of somatic cells could be reprogrammed to a pluripotent state significantly impacted research into therapeutic cloning and the development of stem cell therapies. Given the high rates of morbidity and mortality in the cloning of other mammals, we believe that cloning-to-produce-children would be extremely unsafe, and that attempts to produce a cloned child would be highly unethical.Inthe California legislature declared a "five year moratorium on cloning of an entire human being" and requested that "a panel of representatives from the fields of medicine, religion, biotechnology, genetics, law, bioethics and the general public" be established to evaluate the "medical, ethical and social implications" of human cloning (SB ).

Cloning is no longer a thing of science fiction- it is the present’s most controversial issue. Cloning is complex and involves many people and machines. First, a suitable embryo donor must be found. Majority Recommendation: Ten Members of the Council recommend a ban on cloning-to-produce-children combined with a four-year moratorium on cloning-for-biomedical-research.

Ethics of cloning

We also call for a federal review of current and projected practices of human embryo research, pre-implantation genetic diagnosis, genetic modification of human embryos and gametes, and related matters, with a view to.

Nonetheless, NBAC made every effort to consult widely with ethicists, theologians, scientists, scientific societies, physicians, and others in initiating an analysis of the many scientific, legal, religious, ethical, and moral dimensions of the issue. In contrast to their views on the use of nuclear transfer cloning for basic developmental biology and cell-based therapies, the majority of the societies and associations agreed that the generation of cloned offspring should be prohibited entirely at this time.

Despite the shift to Yamanaka’s technology, this year, a group of US researchers in Oregon successfully derived the first human embryonic stem cell lines using SCNT, both reviving the scientific discussion of reprogramming and the .

An analysis of the views on cloning a controversial issue
Rated 0/5 based on 62 review